Data Centers Bet on Being Switched Off
The quickest way for an AI campus to get power is to promise it can go dark. Texas regulators, a SoftBank write-down and BNEF's emissions math all point the same way.
The way to power for an AI data center no longer runs through a gas turbine order book. It runs through a promise to be switched off.
SoftBank announced a $7.1 billion quarterly loss on Tuesday, and TechCrunch reports that a large part of it came from losses tied to power-generating equipment. The company had reportedly put down deposits on more than 13 gigawatts of turbines, almost 50% more than it needed, according to a Wall Street Journal report that TechCrunch cited. Those deposits were nonrefundable, and SoftBank now treats much of the money as worthless. Meanwhile, Texas's grid operator wants the power to curtail data centers sooner than it can today. Taken together, the evidence says that flexibility, not hardware, is the scarce asset in AI power.
The cost of over-ordering
SoftBank's mistake was rational on its face. Turbine queues now stretch into the early 2030s, TechCrunch reports, so anyone who wanted gas power at scale had to reserve capacity years ahead and pay for the privilege. SoftBank's SB Energy subsidiary said in February that it would spend $33 billion on a 9.2-gigawatt gas plant.
Peter Gardett, CEO of Noreva, read the write-down as a market clearing. "This charge is just that price discovery finally happening." he said, according to TechCrunch. The queue rewarded whoever reserved the most, not whoever needed the most, and reservations without projects behind them are worth little.
TechCrunch does not expect mass cancellations of gas plants, since AI's appetite looks too large. But it says SoftBank may have found its ceiling.
Texas writes the rest of the deal
Interruptible service is already becoming policy in the state with the most data-center ambition. Under current rules, the grid must reach level two of a three-alarm emergency before data centers can be asked to cut demand, Bloomberg reported in a story carried by Insurance Journal. ERCOT CEO Pablo Vegas will ask lawmakers for authority to require cuts at level one, or even earlier.
The stated reason is political as much as technical. "We really don't want to impact residential and everyday businesses if we get into a scarcity event in the state." Vegas said at the BloombergNEF Summit in Houston. Texas passed Senate Bill 6 in 2025 to require large-load customers to reduce use on 24 hours' notice, though ERCOT has not yet ordered a curtailment under it. Vegas said data centers voluntarily cut demand during extreme weather this past winter and have access to supply in the low single-digit-gigawatt range for the coming one.
The industry is leaning into the bargain. Microsoft's Noelle Walsh told the same Houston conference: "We don't want other customers to be paying for our growth." Microsoft plans to build $117 billion of computing capacity this year, Bloomberg reported, so the company has every reason to say it.
Why the grid beats the generator
Flexibility has real headroom behind it. A Duke University Nicholas Institute report, released Feb. 11, 2025, found that the largest 22 US balancing authority areas, which account for 95% of US load, could take on as much as 126 GW of new load if it could be curtailed for 0.25% to 1% of maximum uptime, Utility Dive reported. At the 0.5% rate, that means about 177 hours of curtailment a year. For 88% of the curtailment time, on average, half the new load would keep running. Some utilities, the report noted, quote interconnection delays of seven to 10 years for new large loads. A conditional connection that arrives sooner starts to look generous.
Going off-grid is the costlier answer for the climate too. BNEF finds that if every announced on-site gas plant for US data centers were built and run at its assumptions, they would emit about 345 million metric tons of CO2 equivalent a year. That is more than the same load would produce on average US grid electricity, and the extra alone equals 10% of US power-sector emissions in 2025. "The climate outcome will depend not only on how much electricity these facilities use, but on how quickly grids can connect them." said BloombergNEF's Mark Daly. BNEF concludes that in developed markets such as the US and Europe, grid connection is the more sustainable option.
Brent Nelson of Ascend Analytics, speaking to TechCrunch, reached a similar verdict on cost and risk. Gas carries its own curtailment exposure when winter supplies dip and demand spikes. Most data centers, he said, would be best served by a grid connection, albeit a smaller one than they might normally request, with large batteries to shave peaks or ride out a utility's call to cut.
The counter-argument
The counter-argument is that "curtailable" flatters the load. A preprint by Nils Johnson, Geoff Blanford and John Bistline, submitted 30 Oct 2026 to arXiv, finds that 50 GW can be served while curtailing less than 0.1% of annual energy. But small annual totals hide severe operating demands. In most regions, curtailment must exceed 90% in at least one hour, so the load must disconnect or carry enough on-site resources for full backup. The authors also find that announced data center sites do not line up with modeled headroom. Duke's own work did not consider transmission constraints, which could shrink the room it found.
That objection narrows the thesis rather than breaking it. Full backup for a few hours a year is a far smaller asset than a baseload gas plant. It points toward batteries and modest on-site generation sized for emergencies, not toward gigawatts of turbines sitting behind the meter.
Politics is moving in the same direction. Data centers emerged as a concern in this month's midterms, Bloomberg reported, and Governor Greg Abbott's moratorium on new data-center approvals has held up a giant behind-the-meter project in West Texas by Microsoft, Chevron and Engine No. 1. Abbott lost to Gina Hinojosa, who pledged a potentially tougher stance on permitting. Chevron still aims to have Project Kilby running by 2028 and fully operational by 2031. Malaysia, for its part, plans to charge operators for reserved power they do not use, Tom's Hardware reports, citing Malay Mail.
What follows
If this reading is right, the winners in AI power are the developers who show up with a smaller connection, a battery and a willingness to be told no, not the ones holding stacks of turbine reservations. SoftBank's deposits bought a place in a queue. Vegas's proposal would sell something faster: a place on the wire, with an off switch attached.